[FIXED] [Mage][Arcane] Mana Regen Problem(Mastery)

[Seyrox]

WoW Freakz spell link: https://www.wow-freakz.com/spells.php?spell=190740&&name=mastery-savant
Bug description: So, the formula should be 0.015*baseMana*5. For frost for example it should be 82500 which is okay, but the problem comes for mastery. For example if you have like 70% mastery the math should look like this 0.015*baseMana*5*Mastery, at the moment is 0.015*(baseMana*Mastery)*5*Mastery. The mastery from baseMana is because Savant increases the Maximum Mana and it affects the mana regen, when it should not.
Proof: http://www.askmrrobot.com/wow/theory/mechanic/class/mage?spec=MageArcane&&version=7_1_5_23420

Edit: I tested on Blizzard at level 100 with 19% mastery I had 14k mana regen, and here I have 16.5k almost 17k. I cannot attach printscreens as I accidently installed the Blizzard WoW into the Freakz one and I had to delete everything and the folder with screenshots aswell.



Demonolgy Warlock Guide 5.4.8

[Pinocchio Evreiesc]

Post a screenshot with mana regen view of a trial 100 naked mage from retail, and post one from freakz i guess. I dont think there is anything wrong with mana regen, just a quick look at some arcane mage 7.1.5 dps tests and i see they regen 3% mana in between arcane blast casts at 1.9 sec cast time, i regen the same here (i can post retail vids and vid from here if needed) but i cant be sure of it.

Found a reply here saying:

Quote:

Mana regen is 1.5% of your max mana per second (before Arcane Familiar or special item effects), so this number is fixed.

Which kind of coincides with the ~3% mana over 1.9 sec cast recovery i see.

Still, better wait for kuikzand's opinion.

[Seyrox]

https://imgur.com/a/Gl3Sy

19% mastery 14k mana regen.

https://imgur.com/a/rWWNw

19% mastery almost 17k mana regen.

@Pinocchio Evreiesc



Demonolgy Warlock Guide 5.4.8

[Garn]

Arcane had a nice burst AoE damage on 7.1.5 but mana was their problem.
On freakz they seem to keep their damage for much longer regarding AoE.
I was actually testing mana scailing and spells mana required but never went over mana regeneration.

If this proves to be right then would explain the things mentioned above.


Posting a new BUG REPORT has to follow the template you get when opening a new topic or it can be instantly rejected.

Freakz Lich King 25H

[pinka]

Seyrox wrote:

The mastery from baseMana is because Savant increases the Maximum Mana and it affects the mana regen, when it should not.

in the 2 photos you showed:
1st photo: 19.37 mastery > 191 000 mana > 14325 mana regen every 5 seconds, which would mean roughly 2900 per second.
2st photo: 19.41 mastery > 190 000 mana > 17000 mana regen every 5 seconds, which would mean roughly 3400 per second.

note that u said savant increases the maximum mana... that works correctly.

First of all, Trust me when i say, Arcane mage burst is NOT dependent on the 500 per second mana regen, seeing that most of arcane spells cost a shit ton of mana.
Second of all, pinocchio stated to do the test with both mages naked and see the difference at the base mastery, maybe that will help.
I would agree that if it's not working as intented, it should be fixed, however fixing a small bug like this, compared to hundreds of bugs way more important, i dont see why you would invest time in this.


edit: i have full mastery gear on my mage, max u can get is 40%... where did u get the70% number ?

[Seyrox]

40% means like this, 0.015*BaseMana*5*Mastery(in your case 40%) = 115500 , but it's like this 0.015*BaseMana*Mastery(40% from increased mana pool)*5*Mastery(in your case 40%) = 161700. Since when almost 50k mana regen is low ?

Update @ 19-09-2017, 19:40:01

Also, I had 190k mana in 1 screenshot and 191k mana in another one due to the amount of mastery being different in both scenarios. It just round up but I can assume the difference of actual mana bust be at the most 750 mana.

Update @ 19-09-2017, 19:45:29

Edit2: just to prove my math is correct I have 164018 here https://imgur.com/a/yc2UF

So 0.015*BaseMana*Mastery(41.11% from increased mana pool)*5*Mastery(in your case 41.11%) = 164274.



Confirmed @Quicksand



Demonolgy Warlock Guide 5.4.8

[Quicksand]

Rewrote all mana-regen calculations. Now it uses base mana instead of max mana.