[FIXED] [Priest][Discipline] Drape of Shame vs Atonement

[Elvenking]

WoW Freakz spell link: http://www.wowhead.com/item=142170/drape-of-shame&&bonus=1826:1462
https://www.wow-freakz.com/spells.php?spell=81749 (wowhead link)
Bug description: Critical spell dmg does not increase the healing of atonement by 10% like it should (5% after 7.2 nerf).

Here is my atonement value:


My tests on healing:
No drape of shame ( I had less int on cloak )

Spoiler:

non crit smite


crit smite

With drape of shame

Spoiler:

non crit smite


crit smite

My calculations to this test:
no drape of shame:
435838 crit dmg x 0.511 = 222713 x 1.116 (54 traits in weapon) = 248k heal

with drape of shame:
443238 crit dmg x 0.511 = 226494 x 1,116 = 252767 x 1.1 = 278k heal
heal shown in screen is 253k so obviously a bug.

Proof:
There is tons of proof that it should work, because the critical spell dmg is actually considered a critical heal for atonement (atonement itself can't crit because this would lead to double dipping, but the healing still is considered critical).
https://www.mmo-champion.com/threads/2132214-Drape-of-Shame-DISC
https://us.battle.net/forums/en/wow/topic/20751254957
wowhead comment under drape of shame:

[Vouchery]

Why did you add the 54 trait % it already is added when you deal damage/heal, and as much as possible try to do this naked rather than with the weapon since the weapon has nothing to do with it.

Edit: Confirmed, tested it naked with 2 855 capes with the same stat and both Heal's were the same.


Cho's MW Guide
Class Campaign Guide

[Quicksand]

Fixed