[REJECTED] [Paladin][PvP][PvE] - Guardian of Ancient Kings (Retribution)

[Vanguards]

Wowhead/WoW Freakz Link: https://www.wow-freakz.com/spells.php?spell=86150&&name=guardian-of-ancient-kings
Descrierea bugului / Bug description: Well, theres quite few bugs with this spell.
1) The swing dmg on 4.3 is really low compared to 4.0.6, but Ancient Fury ( the unleash part ) does more on 4.3 than 4.0.6
2) When you summon Guardian and kill someone it wont follow you anymore. It just gonna stand where he killed somebody.
3) Really minor bug, but it should hold a sword, at the moment hes unarmed
Dovada / Proof:

1) Screenshots: 4.3 DMG: http://imgur.com/0Tbol http://imgur.com/1YEnm
4.0.6 DMG: http://imgur.com/qLgnv http://imgur.com/q8iWr

2) Screenshot: http://imgur.com/nS8Ym

3) Screenshot: http://www.skill-capped.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2011/06/guardian_paladin.png

[MindBreaker]

Yea it does more damage with Ancient Fury because you have a better gear -> more ap.
Test it without gear and just one talent point in improved judgement to activate his attacks for retry spec.


4.0.6 Protection Paladin PvE Guide
4.3.4 Demonology Warlock PvE Guide

[Snoppy]

Lol this is not a valid post about melee swing. Add some proofs.
Raster or Groovy or someone which can record a video add this actual bug at the Guardian:
The pet doesnt have the new Pet Assist Stance functionality. It means he doesnt stop when you stop dmg, he doesnt follow, he doesnt change target.

Quote:

Guardian of Ancient Kings uses the new Assist pet stance functionality.

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/game/patch-notes/4-2-0
And btw this bug isnt fix yet:

Quote:

Casting Guardian of Ancient Kings no longer resets the auto-attack swing timer.

from 4.1
and this neither

Quote:

The Retribution version of Guardian of Ancient Kings now benefits from the paladin’s hit and expertise.

If you can find something about haste and mastery which modifies the guardian.


,,Angel Among demons"

[Vanguards]

MindBreaker wrote:

Yea it does more damage with Ancient Fury because you have a better gear -> more ap. Test it without gear and just one talent point in improved judgement to activate his attacks for retry spec.

I do have better gear, but then why swings doing less dmg than I am with Vicious gear ? ..

Alright did another test. This is 4.0.6 no gear http://imgur.com/we35U and this is 4.3 with no gear http://imgur.com/pz8Uz

So it seems on 4.0.6 + Gear swings doing more dmg than on 4.3 + Gear, but

On 4.0.6 does less without gear than on 4.3 without gear.

[MindBreaker]

MindBreaker wrote:

more damage with Ancient Fury

4.0.6 Protection Paladin PvE Guide
4.3.4 Demonology Warlock PvE Guide

[Raster]

Don't compare 4.0.6 to 4.3.4.
Compare blizzard proof with things that happen here, on 4.3.4.


воронья

[Vanguards]

Why not ? It seems that on 4.0.6 it's working fine.

[c3zar]

Because the new patch might bring + or - bonuses to a spell dmg so until you get a clear proof that it should do less/more dmg there is no bug

[Allan]

Problem not only in dmg, on 4.3.4 pet must stop attack target if they get control, for example: if i use Repetance and start cast some heal, pet must stop attack the target instantly (after Repetance) and stay near me, start attack target he must only when i start.And yes Guardian (ret spec) must have a sword.Btw thanks for report, i hope Shocker will fix all this bugs.

P.S. Sorry for my bad english.

[Snoppy]

Raster wrote:

Don't compare 4.0.6 to 4.3.4. Compare blizzard proof with things that happen here, on 4.3.4.

i bought proofs from patch notes.


,,Angel Among demons"

[Allan]

Up...

[Diabolik123]

Use DrDamage to check the damage of the spell and you will see if its bugged or not.

http://www.wowace.com/addons/dr-damage/files/9522-1-9-0_release/

Note : DrDamage scales with all your stats and talents.

http://www.blogcdn.com/wow.joystiq.com/media/2009/10/wi-batcat.jpg

[Vanguards]

Doesnt seem working for guardian. Still kinda annoying that its not confirmed..

[memorabilis]

The direct dmg of the pet is also way too low .It should get atleast 4-6 k normal swings, depending of the resilience of the opponent,but unfortunately it hits 200-400 dmg max which is unnormaly.Im too lazy to create a new post about this.







https://youtube.com/watch?v=NN1R0DK6kss:

[Allan]

Up...