[REJECTED] [Shaman] [Enhancement] Nature Damage trinket scaling - Mastery & Agility

[Doctor Who]

WoW Freakz spell link:
https://www.wow-freakz.com/spells.php?spell=77223&&name=mastery-enhanced-elements
Agility

Bug description and proof:

Compared trinket tolltips on Windwalker Monk, Marksman Hunter, Enhancement Shaman.

Hunter stats:
https://i.imgur.com/iYh6dl6.jpg

Hunter trinket tooltip
https://i.imgur.com/1MrMHPc.jpg

Monk stats:
https://i.imgur.com/w7vU2SS.jpg

Monk trinket tooltip
https://i.imgur.com/ihmWuqp.jpg

Shaman stats:
https://i.imgur.com/G2tmdnx.jpg

Shaman trinket tooltip:
https://i.imgur.com/P4yEdMB.jpg

As you can see in the images above:

1. the shaman trinket does not scale with agility as it does on other agility-based classes.
2. The shaman trinket does not scale with Enhanced Elements (shaman mastery) that is 85%.



As far as I know, it should. The mastery part is not working, for sure. Agility scaling might be an issue as well, as you can see in the screenshots, the shaman has the most agility out of all 3, yet it has the lowest damage.

Done some more testing. Trinket does not scale with landslide 8% agility increase.
Also does not scale with eye of the twisting nether.

check tooltip in the image:
https://i.imgur.com/hbaIUQ4.jpg




Edit:

Further testing shows Mastery does nothing to the trinket tooltip.

https://i.imgur.com/PqTSnuA.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/zOfVk0c.jpg



Pretty gamebreaking issue for enhancement shamans.

[alone1996]

Wow.... Seems there is to much difrence between damage done of this trinket ... I think if agility must affect on damage done of trinkets , shaman must have more damage on tooltip... And shamans mastry increase damage done of nature , frost and fire damages... I think when damage of this trinket is nature must increase it damage too... As well as mastery of afflic warlock affect on trinkets... Plz check it and if u find any problems fix it. Thx

[Doctor Who]

It's versatility-based, agility is irrelevant, but the mastery modifier seems off...anyone can check if retail had a 30% nerf on this specific trinket for shamans?

[Pendenciera]

Try the following item: Terminus signaling beacon (https://www.wow-freakz.com/item_finder.php?item=151969) and try it with different classes, you will get a surprise.


even having 100% mastery, you will take less damage with the trinket than a heal.

[Gushteru]

https://www.wow-freakz.com/spells.php?spell=137041&&name=enhancement-shaman
Check this aura.
Some trinkets have reduced damage for enha to compensate for mastery scaling.
Both terminus and golganet's are present there so reduced damage on them is a thing as this is compensated by mastery scaling (mastery scaling is not mentioned in the tooltip)
Snip from simcraft: https://prnt.sc/tqq5nd
You can see that even there at effect #11 and #12 terminus and golganet are mentioned with their respective nerfs)

[alone1996]

@Gushteru
https://www.wow-freakz.com/spells.php?spell=137031&&name=holy-priest
check this one (Effect #2)
or for other holy and resto classes!
https://www.wow-freakz.com/spells.php?spell=253248&&name=legion-bombardment
will do 2x or 2.5x than enhancement shamans
i can share u some screen shot from damage meter or skada to see their crit is about 3m and shamans crit is 800k :/
enhancment shaman only have mastery for increase damage but resto and holy classes never have any increase damage...
as u can see in higher keys healers equipt legion bomb or other same trinkets that deal aoe damages for doing more damage... so now there is 2 issue!
one : enhanc shaman is nerf
two: or they do more damage ?

[Gushteru]

Healers and tanks also get % damage from traits(every trait is 1.3% damage for healers except disci and 0.65% danage for tanks and disci)
That bonus % damage combined with othwr % damage from traits applies to all damage done including trinkets.
Also disc priest aura was bugged this patch and did not have the modifier till it was fixed, maybe other classes which should have the nerf dont have it and that is why it's dealing so much damage for them
I am not saying it is working correctly for shaman( dont have trinket on any class to test) just pointed out to check spec auras on simcraft (the db on freakz for some classes does not sjow all effects) to see if they have damaged reduction effects applied to them when comparing them to other classes which may not have reduced effects

[Anabolic]

First of all Agility doesn't affect trinket damage afaik,they are affected by your Mastery(if it modifies type of the damage that your trinket deals etc.),versatility and traits.

This is Shaman's aura and you can clearly see that this trinket's effects are nerfed for shaman by 30% which is logical since he deals and empowers nature damage.

Now lets check if everything works.

This is feral's damage without traits,versa.

VS

This is shaman's without mastery

And This is when u add 67.42% mastery do the math damage increased exactly for the same amount as the % of mastery.

Same thing goes for traits,versatility and legendary finger,all of them work as intended because if they didn't then all classes would have the same issue. Rejected.