[FIXED] [REJECTED] [Game Mechanic] Physical vs Magic damage

[kood650]

WoW Freakz spell link:
Character name: Magetest Warriortest Maleferaltes Koodd
Bug description: Physical damage critical chance is being reduced when attacking target with ARMOR (Warriors Mages Druids, possibly all classes).
Proof: Mage (5% crit chance) : https://imgur.com/a/6jyF5EZ
Warrior (5% crit chance) : https://imgur.com/a/VRvx2TG
Druid (5% crit chance balance spec) : https://imgur.com/a/rRwdCkk
Druid (27% crit chance lvl120) : https://imgur.com/a/vpPqcrH


How to reproduce bug:
1st Do not use any buff or code that increases critical chance of the character like in the response of this report: https://forum.wow-freakz.com/REJECTED-Auto-attacks-critical-chance-5-ingame-lower-than-it-should-be-t597619.html
2nd Pick whatever class that has magical dmg spell and test for a target with ARMOR for about 300~500 spells
3rd Auto attack same target for also 300~500 times.

A difference of around 5% in critical chance will be noticed.

Please, i repeat do not use any buff or code that increases critical chance.

[Durotar]

hunter has just the opposite

my crit is 14%

Arcane shot (magic) - 9.0%
http://i.piccy.info/i9/b19ca8c50d4636e5d56ed75b67bde338/1612737335/54473/1414498/95368WoWScrnShot_020821_002211.jpg

Steady shot (physical) - 9.7%
http://i.piccy.info/i9/7a5272b839c8e8e5c85712b42530e628/1612737457/56178/1414498/WoWScrnShot_020821_002221.jpg

Auto shot (physical) - 14.4%
http://i.piccy.info/i9/d5216f4dc28eb407f1bec1ccdf3db485/1612737399/51962/1414498/27105WoWScrnShot_020821_002217.jpg

[Iplayferal]

Look at my bug report here, which got rejected

https://forum.wow-freakz.com/REJECTED-Druid-Feral-Crit-chance-bugged-t596839.html

29% crit chance on my shred with over 40% passive crit and 60% crit while bursting. But got rejected because......reasons.

[Anabolic]

This report is legit conspiracy theory crafting but im gonna break it down for you anyways :

First of all, crit chance is something that works same for everything regardless of spell school or something being a spell or trinket spell or melee etc etc and it has a reduced CD modifier in PvP and once again it works the same for everything unless certain class has its own modifier.

Second, you tested melee crit on an unleveled characters on a raider training dummy in Orgrimmar that is bugged (has issues with armor and many other issues too), while other char was in Zuldazar where dummies work fine. This here alone is a big flaw in your test since not all chars were in same environment and also hitting a target that is way above your level on melee ones.Mage isn't affected by this since spells ignore armor.
Only training dummies that work properly are the ones in zuldazar beside the one that is in front of raider training one, I think that one is a PvP one (idk if it is intended though) and the ones in Boralus work properly too.

Third thing is just because your crit is for example 30% that doesn't mean all your spells will do 30% crit some of them will be at 15% or something, thats just how it is (depends the amount of hits). Because the closer you are to infinity in terms of hits the closer you are to your crit percentage.

And finally here is a proof of physical damage crit chance and azerite crit too properly tested on working dummy and like i said this proof isn't needed since crit works the same way for everything and if it works for one thing there is no reason to assume it doesn't work for a different thing since it is the same script but anyways for the sake of resolving the topic.

CC Value

Melee Hits CC

Trinket Physical proc CC

Melee CC of a pet summoned by trinket

Azerite spell CC And this is pretty much it a lot of different types of CC examples , same crit script and works on same principle and ofcourse approx close to my crit chance and this should pretty much proove that you are wrong.

[FreakzStaff]

Issue is now fixed and moved to Fixed Bugs.

Trello Card Link : https://trello.com/c/G8tJRkQ4/569-critical-chance-issue-on-melee