[REJECTED] [Hunter][Beast Mastery] Kill Command doing too much damage

[Nescius]

WoW Freakz spell link: https://www.wow-freakz.com/spells.php?spell=34026&&name=kill-command
Bug description: Kill Command does approximately 30% more damage than it should be doing.
Proof:
Simulationcraft 7.2.5-01 version shows that my pet's average kill command hits should do about 660k damage while the average crit should do about 1.37 million damage, but the in game numbers are far higher.

As you can see, in game my pet's average Kill command hits do about 945k damage while the average crits are 1.98 million. Now the average numbers can change depending on the procs I get, allowing me to cast more Beastial Wraths and do more damage that way, but the maximum damage my pet's kill command does is also way off than what simulationcraft says it should be. My in game maximum hits is 1.32 million and maximum critical hit is 2.65 million.

While the simcraft numbers are 899k maximum hit and 1.81 million maximum crit.


Now this could also be a bug in simulationcraft's values on its own so I had to bring up some examples from retail itself.


For the record, these tests were done on a 937 ilvl hunter with minimal mastery gear and high haste gear with 32% haste and 60% mastery, using a haste food on top of that. So keep in mind that the hunters in the top logs I'm going to link have a lot more mastery than me, which should result in their Kill command doing more damage than mine due to how BM mastery works.

My hunter's average Kill command cast is doing 1.29 million damage while the top third fourth and first (respectively) logging BM hunters in 7.2.5 with 937-938 gear are doing way less damage than mine with their kill command's.
https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/DC3zZWJjB7pacnGH#fight=4&&type=damage-done&&source=30
https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/np4tVZjCNgk8GBRY#fight=29&&type=damage-done&&source=12
https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/Tfg8hZFQpd7kDAX9#fight=1&&type=damage-done&&source=6

As can be seen here, their pet's average Kill command cast is doing about 1.03 million damage while mine is doing 1.29 million despite having less mastery.



The same issue can be seen in Hati's kill command damage as well when compared to the numbers shown by simulationcraft as well as the damage numbers from retail logs.

[visualex2]

I think before posting something you should double check what you want to post.First of all you brought irrelevant proofs.
In other order of ideas Kill Comand do with 15% less than he should do because 4p bonus is not working .My normal hit of Kill Comand do like 590k and a critical strike hit is 900k-1.1M
You have a lot of things who increase damage for Kill Comand like Concordance ,Pack Leader,Unleashed the Beast,2p bonus from Nightold,2p bonus from TOS who increase damage by 1,5% every 1 second .
Just try to calculate this numbers and you will see everything is normal with KC .See this proofs :
-https://imgur.com/51BidHF without BW
-https://imgur.com/FdsTgqx with BW
-And during BW you need to calculate 2p Nightold who increase damage by 10%,BW who increase damage by 48 % and add 1,5% more every 1 second until you reach 60-65% more damage increase and my Concordance who is right now 5500 more agility .
-Basic atack 600k +(58% from 600k)+(concordance)=600k+348k+around 150k concordance=1,1M Genius and you can see in recount 1 M normal hit and 1,6M maxim because the damage increase is stacking every 1 second by 1,5%
Everything is working normal with Kill Comand, and as i said hes damage is with 15% less because 4p Bonus is not working.

[Nescius]

I don't think you quite understand the point of my post. The thread is titled "Kill Command doing too much damage". I'm saying Kill Command does more damage than it's supposed to do, not less and it has nothing to do with the 4p bonus as I'm not even using 4p ToS set yet. Doing simple maths just doesn't prove why my damage on freakz is much higher than simcraft or the logs on retail . Please try to reread the post before taking a condescending approach.

[visualex2]

Nescius wrote:

I don't think you quite understand the point of my post. The thread is titled "Kill Command doing too much damage". I'm saying Kill Command does more damage than it's supposed to do, not less and it has nothing to do with the 4p bonus as I'm not even using 4p ToS set yet. Doing simple maths just doesn't prove why my damage on freakz is much higher than simcraft or the logs on retail . Please try to reread the post before taking a condescending approach.

Kill Comand is working fine .Bring some relevant proofs.

[Nescius]

The proofs are right there, my average and maximum Kill command damage on freakz is way higher than what simulationcraft thinks I should be doing, as well as being way higher than even the best BM hunters with high mastery gear ever did. Please try to reread my post before dismissing it as "irrelevant".

[visualex2]

Nescius wrote:

The proofs are right there, my average and maximum Kill command damage on freakz is way higher than what simulationcraft thinks I should be doing, as well as being way higher than even the best BM hunters with high mastery gear ever did. Please try to reread my post before dismissing it as "irrelevant".

How can you know how much mastery and how many Concordance Traits that guy has? To play on mastery build is more better than on haste.So how can you know that guy don;t play at 100% mastery and 15% haste?

[Nescius]

You can check his items and what item level his items are from the summary page here
https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/np4tVZjCNgk8GBRY#fight=29&&type=summary&&source=12

His total mastery is 10.126 with gems applied, which is way higher than the measly 7540 mastery my hunter has.

[CyberKing]

Since there is not much proof here I had to test and make a separate bug report about Kill Command https://forum.wow-freakz.com/Hunter-Beast-Mastery-Bestial-Wrath-vs-Kill-Command-t559267.html. After this is fixed I believe there will be no more problems with Kill Command. If something else pops up report it or let me know.

"The optimist thinks this is the best of all possible worlds. The pessimist fears it is true."