[REJECTED] [Pirest][Disc] Mastery vs Atonement

[Firespell]

WoW Freakz spell link: https://www.wow-freakz.com/spells.php?spell=81749&&name=atonement
Bug description: Mastery dose not effect to atonemet at all
additional : in the calculation formula it working fine and we can see correct numbers in the tooltip even
but healing that transfer trough atonement will not increase at all when we increase mastery.

Proof: 1st pic , without any gear https://imgur.com/a/vIQVOuH

19058 *45.1/100 ~ 8.6k ( which working fine)


2nd pic , full mastery gear (57% = 11.102) https://imgur.com/a/PZhhFxY
274.677 * 45.1/100 = 123k
(with 11k mastery it calculate with 45.1% again which means mastery did not effect it)
however it should be like 274.677 * 62.9/100 = 172k

[Ein]

The mastery works fine.
When you calculate atonement healing you must substract the dmg increase from artifact trait. (evry point in artifact gain + 0,65% dmg)
proof: The damage bonus you get for each trait in the weapon (0.5% per point (old patch)) does not transfer to Atonement.

Spoiler:

https://us.battle.net/forums/en/wow/topic/20753315894

Example:
My stat:
- 56145 int
- 5,92% versa
- n° traits 60 (+39% dmg)
- 46,98% mastery (58,8% dmg trasferred throug atonement)

I take the spell smite the base intellect value is 260% plus modifiers like:
- invoke the light, artifact trait, +15% dmg
- forbidden flame , artifact, + 5% dmg and heal (doesent doubledip)
- will of the conclave, +10% dmg and heal (doesen't doubledip)
- 1 sins's of many, +1% dmg

so the dmg of smite is:
teorical dmg = 56145 (int) * 2,6 (base int value) *1,39 (artifact dmg) * 1,0592 (versa) * 1,15 ( invoke) * 1,05 (forbidden) * 1,1 (conclave) * 1,01 (sins) = 288322k
toerical heal = 56145 (int) * 2,6 (base int value) *0,4 (base aton) *1,4698 (mastery) * 1,0592 (versa) * 1,15 ( invoke) * 1,05 (forbidden) * 1,1 (conclave) * 1,01 (sins) = 121950 k
dmg on freaks = 296k
heal on freaks = 122k

Spoiler:

in your example if you take 173k and divide it by the dmg increase from trait ( 1,39% i suppose you have 60 trait) you gain 123k atonement healing
173k /1,39 = 123k

for discussion about disci priest you can contatct me in game i'm Aint.

[Firespell]

Ein wrote:

The mastery works fine. When you calculate atonement healing you must substract the dmg increase from artifact trait. (evry point in artifact gain + 0,65% dmg) proof: The damage bonus you get for each trait in the weapon (0.5% per point (old patch)) does not transfer to Atonement. Spoiler: https://us.battle.net/forums/en/wow/topic/20753315894 Example: My stat: - 56145 int - 5,92% versa - n° traits 60 (+39% dmg) - 46,98% mastery (58,8% dmg trasferred throug atonement) I take the spell smite the base intellect value is 260% plus modifiers like: - invoke the light, artifact trait, +15% dmg - forbidden flame , artifact, + 5% dmg and heal (doesent doubledip) - will of the conclave, +10% dmg and heal (doesen't doubledip) - 1 sins's of many, +1% dmg so the dmg of smite is: teorical dmg = 56145 (int) * 2,6 (base int value) *1,39 (artifact dmg) * 1,0592 (versa) * 1,15 ( invoke) * 1,05 (forbidden) * 1,1 (conclave) * 1,01 (sins) = 288322k toerical heal = 56145 (int) * 2,6 (base int value) *0,4 (base aton) *1,4698 (mastery) * 1,0592 (versa) * 1,15 ( invoke) * 1,05 (forbidden) * 1,1 (conclave) * 1,01 (sins) = 121950 k dmg on freaks = 296k heal on freaks = 122k Spoiler: in your example if you take 173k and divide it by the dmg increase from trait ( 1,39% i suppose you have 60 trait) you gain 123k atonement healing 173k /1,39 = 123k for discussion about disci priest you can contatct me in game i'm Aint.

no need a complicated calculation , also i cant trust to a random spoilers , i will just do another test by removing artifact weapon and ill post the result here

[Dannyboy001]

I have an even simpler solution, I have a mastery trinket, so I tried a smiting a dummy with atonement on myself, without then with the trinket. If what you're saying is right and mastery doesn't do jackshit then there should be no difference.

https://imgur.com/a/Inj9vk4

Smite damage is the same, however healing has increased by 5k. Mastery does scale atonement healing up.
As for why it heals less than what it should according to tooltips, Ein explained it correctly, every trait increases your damage by 0.65%, but that does not count towards your healing.

The light has abandoned you!

[Barnacle]

The disc Mastery is working properly.

XXX Barney