[REJECTED] [Priest][Disc] Atonement's healing Vs critical strikes

[abbasgon]

WoW Freakz spell link:

https://www.wow-freakz.com/spells.php?spell=81749&&name=atonement

Bug description:

Hotfix (2013-03-05): "Atonement healing granted from critical strikes now heal for the correct amount."

Proof:

https://wow.gamepedia.com/Atonement

[Elvenking]

Can't find a bug with crit dmg vs atonement heal. Please provide proper proof or i have to reject this.

Here some calculations done with my priest (got 15% heal inc trait and drape of shame equipped):


The 1.2k difference is most probably some rounding error so it's negligibly.

[abbasgon]

i mean for ex your smite is cirit yes ? it must be show your Atonement is critical too.

i check video in blizz. it show your Atonement is critical when your next spell is cirit.


Proof :

For some reason this 'crit atonement heal' (your damage spell critting) is shown as a crit in the battle log.

https://eu.battle.net/forums/en/wow/topic/17614111977

[Barnacle]

Atonement itself can not crit, so any critical strikes that you see are when the spell that causes the heal crits. It's working properly as far as I can see


XXX Barney

[abbasgon]

well i just wait for Elvenking

[Elvenking]

Atonement heal can't crit, otherwise it would be completely broken and heal for more than the dmg does with just 50% dmg/heal modifier.

So it works correctly as of now.

Some discussion on retail about this here: https://eu.battle.net/forums/en/wow/topic/17614111977

Basically if the atonement heal would be able to crit itself too it would result in double dipping as the damage part crits and heal too then.
Any effect that can critical strike can do this only one time.