[Raid] The Nighthold: Gul'dan

[Flamestalker]

Please post here any bug you found regarding The Nighthold: Gul'dan encounter, Normal, Heroic, Mythic
FIRST REALM WILL BE DELAYED FOR 1 WEEK AFTER THE MYTHIC LAUNCH
if you want to confirm a bug that it's been already reported please just use - like - button, otherwise we will delete your post
write difficulty and bug found
use this feature [spoiler] for youtube videos please so i can track each bug you post without scrolling my whole screen
[PENDING] - [FIXED]

• [FIXED] Fixed an issue where health of Eye of Gul'dan was higher than intended.
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue where health of Empowered Eye of Gul'dan was higher than intended.
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue where Empowered Bonds of Fel was knock backing players forwards instead of backwards.
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue where Gul'dan's sphere was knocking players away upon entering phase one, and LoS problems with it.
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue where travel time of Liquid Hellfire was too fast.
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue where Liquid Hellfire damage was lower then intended.
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue where Gul'dan's knockback upon entering phase two was too big.
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue where Gul'dan's Fel Efflux hit radius was too big.
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue with Empowered Eye of Gul'dan hitbox being too small.
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue with Gul'dan's energy bar.
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue with Eye of Gul'dan and Empowered Eye of Gul'dan timers.
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue with Eye of Gul'dan targeting melee, they will only target ranged dps from now on.
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue where Bonds of Fel and Empowered Bonds of Fel could be casted on both tanks.
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue with Violent Winds timers.
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue where Storm of the Destroyer was pushing players away (Storm should not have any kind of pushback or wind effect).
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue where Flames of Sargeras were leaving 5 instead of 4 patches of fire.
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue where Soul Corrosion was doing more damage then intended.
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue where Scattering Field was not absorbing the correct amount of damage on Mythic difficulty.
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue where Gul'dans hitbox was too small on Mythic difficulty.
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue where Violent Winds on Normal and Heroic would never end.
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue where D'zorykx the Trapper and Fel Lord Kuraz'mal were despawning after transitioning to the second phase on Mythic.
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue where D'zorykx the Trapper Soul Vortex lasted longer then intended.
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue where Parasitic Shadow Demons were moving while CCed.
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue where Parasitic Shadow Demons were absorbing more damage then intended.
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue with hitboxes in the last phase of the fight on Mythic.
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue with Nightorb cast time of Distortion Aura.
  
• [FIXED] Fixed an issue where Empowered Eye of Gul'dan didn't follow the target that had agro on it. (needs restart)
  

[f0rnetty]

i think the eyes of gul'dan have too much HP they have 106m and when i looked on yt they only had 22m
also they might cast duplicate too fast but im not sure about this one

[yeticek]

we found a bug which result in dropping whole server.

eyes of guldan spawn endlessly as u can see on screen. On normal diff they should have less than 100 mega HP per eye is overkill on mythic it should have 29 mega

Code:

http://www.wowhead.com/npc=105630/eye-of-guldan

[Shocker]

yeticek wrote:

we found a bug which result in dropping whole server. eyes of guldan spawn endlessly as u can see on screen. On normal diff they should have less than 100 mega HP per eye is overkill on mythic it should have 29 mega Code: http://www.wowhead.com/npc=105630/eye-of-guldan

Yes, this is the reason of the recent crashes, disabled that part temporarily

FREAKZ COMMUNITY @ Facebook
WOW FREAKZ @ Facebook

[CocoDev]

f0rnetty wrote:

i think the eyes of gul'dan have too much HP they have 106m and when i looked on yt they only had 22m also they might cast duplicate too fast but im not sure about this one

Fixed the health part. Now, you can watch any youtube video you might want and you can see that Eye of Gul'dan is casting Duplicate ones every 10 seconds, therefore his energy is increased by 10/second.

[darkwavecze]

The eyes didn't duplicate when they finished their cast.

Can't bring proof, forgot to record.

edit: srry, didn't read properly.

[CocoDev]

darkwavecze wrote:

The eyes didn't duplicate when they finished their cast. Can't bring proof, forgot to record.

As Shocker said, he disabled the Duplicate mechanic for the moment, we are trying to fix the crash issue, after that the spell will be enabled again.

[ilivanfil]

Spell: Soul Corrosion https://www.wowdb.com/spells/208802-soul-corrosion
In 7.1.5: Up time 15 sec / No 3 min.
Proof

Damage (7.1.5)
Effect 1 ( AOE damage): 202 000 shadow damage within 5 yards
Effect 2 ( single damage): 107 376 Shadow damage 15 sec!

==============================================

Damage (7.2)
Effect 1 ( AOE damage): 236 000 shadow damage within 5 yards
Effect 2 ( single damage): 30 000 Shadow damage 3 Min!

[CocoDev]

ilivanfil wrote:

Spell: Soul Corrosion https://www.wowdb.com/spells/208802-soul-corrosion In 7.1.5: Up time 15 sec / No 3 min. Proof Damage (7.1.5) Effect 1 ( AOE damage): 202 000 shadow damage within 5 yards Effect 2 ( single damage): 107 376 Shadow damage 15 sec! ============================================== Damage (7.2) Effect 1 ( AOE damage): 236 000 shadow damage within 5 yards Effect 2 ( single damage): 30 000 Shadow damage 3 Min!

Fixed, already live.


Edit:

I will revert the fix, we did some more in-depth research and we found out that there was a hidden hotfix around Jan 17, 2017 (7.1.5) which increased the duration from 15s to 3 minutes, blizzard announced it in their changelog later after patch 7.2.0 was released.

[ilivanfil]

Need prof. because in (Tue Jan 10 2017) Build 23360 spell time 15 sec. Damage nefed
https://blue.mmo-champion.com/topic/793394-hotfixes-january-17/
https://worldofwarcraft.com/en-us/news/20478238/hotfixes-january-17



Look log on this spell:

In 7.0.3 (13.12.2016) Spell time 15 sec 270k damage
7.1.5 (15.01.2017) Spell 15 sec 145k damage
In 7.2 ( 07.07.2017) Spell Time 3 min and 30k damage .
7.1 15 sec work.
7.2 3m

i use web arhive. And Blue post/ Hot fix And Hidden hot fix

CocoDev wrote:

ilivanfil wrote: Spell: Soul Corrosion https://www.wowdb.com/spells/208802-soul-corrosion In 7.1.5: Up time 15 sec / No 3 min. Proof Damage (7.1.5) Effect 1 ( AOE damage): 202 000 shadow damage within 5 yards Effect 2 ( single damage): 107 376 Shadow damage 15 sec! ============================================== Damage (7.2) Effect 1 ( AOE damage): 236 000 shadow damage within 5 yards Effect 2 ( single damage): 30 000 Shadow damage 3 Min! Fixed, already live. Edit: I will revert the fix, we did some more in-depth research and we found out that there was a hidden hotfix around Jan 17, 2017 (7.1.5) which increased the duration from 15s to 3 minutes, blizzard announced it in their changelog later after patch 7.2.0 was released.

[KremX]

This is a Heroic world first kill and Soul Corrosion lasts for 3min (Video)
It was uploaded on Jan 18, 2017 meaning it was 7.1.5, 7.2.0 was released on March 28, 2017.

[Imbafaceroll]

stewa91 wrote:

This is a Heroic world first kill and Soul Corrosion lasts for 3min (Video) It was uploaded on Jan 18, 2017 meaning it was 7.1.5, 7.2.0 was released on March 28, 2017.

The thing is whichever version you choose from the patch notes of [Soul Corrosion] - is not what we have on the live server.
Right now we have a 3 min. debuff with 100k damage per stack. What we are arguing for is that it should either be 15 sec debuff with 100k damage per stack, or if you please then it can be a 3 min debuff but in that case it should be only 30k damage per stack.

Same source, different timestamp - https://youtube.com/watch?v=EnYhW-z55s8&t=8:


Monitor the hunter 'Fenri' (4th row, 2nd column on raid frames). He does indeed get a 3 min. debuff, but that's clearly nowhere near 100k damage per stack.

Choose wisely, our current client build has a baked in tooltip for it to last 15 sec though (:

[ilivanfil]

You right.
Spell time 3 min.
tooltip is not correct. ( visual bug)/ But damade is not correct. Video first kill Hm i see 2 char have 8 stuck. (30k*8=240k .On freakz in normal 2 stuck 240k!!!)
Damage scaling for Raid:

=====Soul Corrosion======= (for 1 stack)

warcraftlogs.com

stewa91 wrote:

This is a Heroic world first kill and Soul Corrosion lasts for 3min (Video) It was uploaded on Jan 18, 2017 meaning it was 7.1.5, 7.2.0 was released on March 28, 2017.

Update @ 02-04-2018, 14:00:02

HP bug in Gul Dan

30 ppl Gul dan 3600M (01/04/18 Freakz)

GulDan HP and HP add




PS Scaling all boss/add in NH(N/HM) incorrect

[ilivanfil]

Soul_Corrosion_Damage_Normal=4500+1000*((Raid_Size)-((Raid_Size)-1))
Raid_size=[10;30]
================================================
Soul_Corrosion_Damage_Heroic=10000+1000*((Raid_Size)-((Raid_Size)-1))
Raid_size=[10;30]

[Imbafaceroll]

ilivanfil wrote:

Soul_Corrosion_Damage_Normal=4500+1000*((Raid_Size)-((Raid_Size)-1)) Raid_size=[10;30] ================================================ Soul_Corrosion_Damage_Heroic=10000+1000*((Raid_Size)-((Raid_Size)-1)) Raid_size=[10;30]

I think I found a bug in the formula, if you strip the brackets:

Code:

Soul_Corrosion_Damage_Normal = = 4500 + 1000 * [ <Raid_Size> - {(Raid_Size)-1} ] = = 4500 + 1000 * [ <Raid_Size> - (Raid_Size) + 1 ] = = 4500 + 1000 * [ Raid_Size - Raid_Size + 1 ] = = 4500 + 1000 * [ 1 ] = = 4500 + 1000 = 5500

it produces a constant of '5500'
most likely, one of the Raid_Size should be Raid_Max_Size or 30 for short
also even then it returns values in reverse (highest damage for 10 man and lowest damage for 30 man)

Assuming 5.5k to 25.5k damage was intended, I propose following formula

Code:

Soul_Corrosion_Damage_Normal = 1000 * (MAX(Raid_Size, 10) - 5) + 500

which produces following results:

Spoiler:

10 - 5500
11 - 6500
12 - 7500
13 - 8500
14 - 9500
15 - 10500
16 - 11500
17 - 12500
18 - 13500
19 - 14500
20 - 15500
21 - 16500
22 - 17500
23 - 18500
24 - 19500
25 - 20500
26 - 21500
27 - 22500
28 - 23500
29 - 24500
30 - 25500