[REJECTED] [Warrior][Fury] Khaz'goroth's Courage

[Skillshot]

WoW Freakz spell link: https://www.wow-freakz.com/spells.php?spell=256826&&name=worldforger-s-flame
Bug description: The trinket does way too much damage (~2x or more) on a fury warrior, probably the scaling is wrong since the proc rate seems fine, but also should be looked into.
Proof: https://imgur.com/rfwevKd vs the logs from retail on the same fight https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/kRc7XDPw6txH8B1m#fight=13&&type=damage-done&&source=25 (notice 7% of dmg done)

[Mighty]

Lucky parse.Comparing to the retail thing is silly,the guy u linked had 37% haste vs this one with over 50-55%.More haste means faster autoattacks=more autoattacks=more trinket dmg.Combine that with lucky rng procs during ur burst and u get this result.This is easy to test out,go on a dummy,run 10 tests and see on how many of those 10 tests u have that uptime on the trinket.It will happen once,twice,maybe not at all but ur trinket in general will be around 9%ish.Link his trinket dmg on other fights too.

[Skillshot]

bgdbogdan90 wrote:

Lucky parse.Comparing to the retail thing is silly,the guy u linked had 37% haste vs this one with over 50-55%.More haste means faster autoattacks=more autoattacks=more trinket dmg.Combine that with lucky rng procs during ur burst and u get this result.This is easy to test out,go on a dummy,run 10 tests and see on how many of those 10 tests u have that uptime on the trinket.It will happen once,twice,maybe not at all but ur trinket in general will be around 9%ish.Link his trinket dmg on other fights too.

Not a lucky parse, every run the % of damage done is about ~15 of total damage done. The retail link is practically the same ilvl.

bgdbogdan90 wrote:

This is easy to test out,go on a dummy,run 10 tests and see on how many of those 10 tests u have that uptime on the trinket.It will happen once,twice,maybe not at all but ur trinket in general will be around 9%ish.Link his trinket dmg on other fights too

we've gotten class mods, who can easily replicate this on the Dev real, be it with 35% haste or higher...

[palosipetya]

On legion Kelade had like 50-60ish % mastery... this trinket, as all trinkets, scales with mastery...

[Skillshot]

palosipetya wrote:

On legion Kelade had like 50-60ish % mastery... this trinket, as all trinkets, scales with mastery...

Did you even read what was reported? In case of retail - Kelade's case (that was a totally random parse select), the trinket did 7% of his damage [including all the mastery scaling you've mentioned]. Here on freakz, it does more than 15% of the total damage done... Could be haste, could be mastery could be wrong scaling, I don't know.

[overpowerz]

so u r qq about warrior trinket when warrior on server totaly broken lol god dam ppl

[palosipetya]

It could be pure luck, if the trinket procs during a battlecry window it does 3x its original damage. The trinket works as intended, youve just seen a lucky case thats all.

[Skillshot]

palosipetya wrote:

It could be pure luck, if the trinket procs during a battlecry window it does 3x its original damage. The trinket works as intended, youve just seen a lucky case thats all.

Oh yes, instead of actually checking let's say it's pure luck and be done with it. "stop inventing bugs" )

[Mighty]

Look,im not trying to be rude nor defending anythig but ur post is meh.Why?Cause 1)u could have gather more info and show the conclusion u came to2)the fact that u didnt post more pictures,idont see the point of only posting 1 picture instead of more since u claimed it did 15% on every fight u could have shown that.As someone above mentioned,the ammount of rng involved(like proc lines up ur cds),bis stats and weapon ilvl u can get in here makes the comparission to retail or any comparassion kinda meh.Im not saying it shouldnt be looked up into but ive runned multiple tests(and i always got the same result:raging blow always 1st on dmg metters>rampage>melee attacks>~bloodthirst>trinket>odyn's fury),bl and non bl and on that ammount of dmg i cant get near that trinket dmg this is why i personally belive it was a lucky parse.You can imagine that over the course of 3 months of 7.3 someone would have noticed if it would do 15% on every fight.

[Skillshot]

bgdbogdan90 wrote:

Look,im not trying to be rude nor defending anythig but ur post is meh.Why?Cause 1)u could have gather more info and show the conclusion u came to2)the fact that u didnt post more pictures,idont see the point of only posting 1 picture instead of more since u claimed it did 15% on every fight u could have shown that.As someone above mentioned,the ammount of rng involved(like proc lines up ur cds),bis stats and weapon ilvl u can get in here makes the comparission to retail or any comparassion kinda meh.Im not saying it shouldnt be looked up into but ive runned multiple tests(and i always got the same result:raging blow always 1st on dmg metters>rampage>melee attacks>~bloodthirst>trinket>odyn's fury),bl and non bl and on that ammount of dmg i cant get near that trinket dmg this is why i personally belive it was a lucky parse.You can imagine that over the course of 3 months of 7.3 someone would have noticed if it would do 15% on every fight.

mate, I'm no keyboard warrior....

Do and believe whatever you like, the point is simple - the trinket does insane amount of damage, here you go with more data from the same boss (I kept the player name, though I didn't want to disclose it initially):

another try with 16% damage - https://imgur.com/x7tGkSL
and another one with 12% damage done - https://imgur.com/E5Lv5iG

If it's considered a specific scaling thing peculiar to freakz, so be it.

I've taken a boss fight with live-retail data as reference.
Comments that relate to "it's meh to me" or that "over the course of 3 months no one reported", are non-valid to me.
If a class mod checks it and says that it's fine, then it's fine, case closed - no point in arguing of proving anything.

P.S. consider this a last reply to your comments.

[Coxman]

comparing a donated warrior on a private server to a warrior on retail is kinda weird, they dont have the same stats, a donated warrior has more stats kelade with 976 ilvl and cobi 981.

Also kelade is doing more dps than cobi that explains that private servers doesnt work like intended and should fix bloodbath and 2pc bonus of T21, also what you didnt mention is the fight duration that log is showing a 4:40 min you should have compared that to cobi's fight

[Mighty]

Mate,even 2 sims dont match one with another and u want a freakz log to match literally entirely a retail log.The 16% picture u linked a 270m total dmg bl fight,lol,thats like a 1min and abit fight(u dont count the intermission,the bridge phase as time since u dont have any uptime or dps on the boss).Like after bl lets stop and check how much dps an autoattack buff trinket does with every haste buff on a class which already has high ammount of haste and autoattack speed buffs.Imonar fights provides u enough time in between bridge phases(since its gonna take a while to cross and until u interrupt the boss,even 30s),in that time ur procs have the time to reset,ur cds are coming back so u almost lineup everything after every bridge phase ,outside of other lineups.This is why i told u to run multiple tests,5min tests like antorus fights are and make an average uptime of the trinket from all the logs.Just because few times it did 15% and some other times it did 9% that doesn mean it should do 15 or 9 every fight,its still too much rng involved to take one result as a definitive must always be result.U expect an rng proc based trinket to match exactly other logs,lol.

[sharrk]

No coment

[sharrk]

ela 976 chek dmg http://kachi-snimka.info/images-2013/bwy1591574669j.jpg

[Skillshot]

@sharrk, can you write that in English, please?