[Warrior][Arms] Precise Strikes

[Maev]

WoW Freakz spell link: https://www.wow-freakz.com/spells.php?spell=248579 (wowhead link)
Bug description: [Precise Strikes] should have 10%, not 8 %, it misses 2 % per point acquire and for 4 points that you can get is a total of 8 % missing which is something.
The 8% per point is from 7.3 when he gets nerf.
Proof:

7.2.5 (Mon Jun 12 2017) Build 24430

https://www.wow-freakz.com/spells.php?spell=248579 (wowhead link)

[Mazar]

simC 725-01

Name : Precise Strikes (id=248579) [Spell Family (4), Passive, Hidden]
School : Physical
Range : 100 yards
Proc Chance : 101%
Artifact Power : Id: 1149, Index: 9, Max Rank: 8, Values: [ 8, 16, 24, 32, 40, 48, 56, 64 ]
Proc Flags : ....x... ........ ........ ........
: Yellow Melee
Attributes : ......xx ........ ........ .......x ........ ........ ........ ........
: ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ......x.
: ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........
: ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........
: ........ ....x... ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........
: ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........
: Passive (6), Hidden (7), Cannot cancel aura (31)
Effects :
#1 (id=465705) : Apply Aura (6) | Dummy (4)
Base Value: 8 | Scaled Value: 8 | Target: Self (1)
Hotfixed: Chain Multiplier (0 -> 1)
Description : Colossus Smash increases the critical strike chance of your next Mortal Strike or Execute by $s1%.

Its simC from 2017-07-03 so it was 8% before patch 7.3.

[Don.LukyaNo]

https://www.wowhead.com/news=263129/all-the-class-and-artifact-trait-changes-in-patch-7-2-5 Look at the warrior section it says clearly.On 7.2.5 it was modified from 15% per trait to 10% per trait.And now look at the 7.3 patch notes for warrior on the same exact trait https://www.wowhead.com/news=268721/all-class-changes-in-patch-7-3
All in all it should be 10% per trait this patch and 8% next patch.

[Mighty]

@Mazar in which universe u have max rank 8 on traits on 7.2.5?

[Don.LukyaNo]

bgdbogdan90 wrote:

@Mazar in which universe u have max rank 8 on traits on 7.2.5?

Yeah that is probably info from 7.3 P.T.R or something like that.8th rank is achieved only on 7.3 with the Netherlight Crucible also it's rather simple to just check patch notes and see how the said trait was modified.

[IronWill]

Most of the nerfs blizz has done were at the end of 7.2.5 patch and during 7.3 ptr. (the legendary items nerf too)
So it's practically 7.3(~1-2 weeks till launch)... same should be done here, 1-2 weeks before next patch they can apply those nerfs.

They should take in consideration this fact and revert some invalid "fixes" they did.

[zeus157]

That doesn't make any sense. The legendary nerfs happened when the server was IN 7.2.5. The warrior nerfs happened IN 7.3. A GM replied to one of the legendary nerfs by saying ''this server is based on the last build of 7.2.5.'' So, the 1-2 weeks from 7.3 logic doesn't apply here. The bug is legit and must be fixed.

[NurZooL]

As mentioned above, Precise Strikes - Colossus Smash increases the critical strike chance of your next Mortal Strike or Execute by 10% on 7.2.5 and 8% on 7.3

[Shocker]

I am not convinced it should be 10% on 7.2.5. Even SimC shows it's 8 on 7.2.5 https://www.wow-freakz.com/spells.php?spell=248579&&simc and as far as we know SimC data is 99.99% correct

FREAKZ COMMUNITY @ Facebook
WOW FREAKZ @ Facebook

[Blyst]

Will check into it by tomorrow

Do you know what it FEELS like, to be TORTURED by your own mind?

[Maev]

Shocker wrote:

I am not convinced it should be 10% on 7.2.5. Even SimC shows it's 8 on 7.2.5 https://www.wow-freakz.com/spells.php?spell=248579&&simc and as far as we know SimC data is 99.99% correct

So you're saying that Wowhead Changelog is garbage

[Skillshot]

Shocker wrote:

I am not convinced it should be 10% on 7.2.5. Even SimC shows it's 8 on 7.2.5 https://www.wow-freakz.com/spells.php?spell=248579&&simc and as far as we know SimC data is 99.99% correct

AFAIK, simc 7.2.5 - 02 has the scalings from 7.3, at least thats what I’ve been told numerous times when trying to link simcraft spells and their respective scaling formulas. I’ve also been given a specific build which I was told the devs are based on, maybe things changed. But the important part is that 7.2.5-02 has the scalings from 7.3

Just to prove my point:

One of the reports on elemental shaman damage which had no fixes applied at that time and the sims were based on 7.2.5-02, the report was rejected due to the fact that I simmed with 7.2.5-02 [which, was reported as having 7.3 scalings]

https://forum.wow-freakz.com/Shaman-Elemental-Lava-Burst-Earth-Shock-and-general-10-to-30-lower-damage-on-abilities-t545934.html

I've been given the "correct" simc version by a staff/helper member:

https://imgur.com/y465hom
https://imgur.com/a/ImOUrlN


P.S.

Maybe things have changed, and you take as a refference the scalings from the V."02", but it's endpatch and actual 7.3. As a result, arms warrior probably "suffered" significant nerfs, and probably other classes some buffs... Anyways, my point is that they should be aligned to a single point of refference.

[IronWill]

Maybe a bit off topic, but important.

https://imgur.com/a/ImOUrlN

Quote:

Only thing simcraft can't check is everything PVP related, thats why I compare pvp template to retail videos...

So it is true that simC can't actually check PvP related stuff? This means we play with some custom inaccurate PvP templates, seems logic now why damage of some classes in pvp is lower than retail. What I can't understand in this case is, why our bug reports with video proof get trashed?

[Blyst]

Precise Strikes should be 10% not 8%


- https://www.wowhead.com/news=263129/all-the-class-and-artifact-trait-changes-in-patch-7-2-5
- https://www.wowhead.com/news=268721/all-class-changes-in-patch-7-3
- You can have RANK 7 (in 7.2.5) on your Precise Strikes, not RANK 8 (in 7.3)


Which means it should be 10%